168596-WF

Roger Submitted this review about Ship a Car Direct
Review made Live: 5/23/2010 12:40:00 AM
This was my first time moving across country and I was quite nervous about shipping my car shipped. I chose Honesty First because of the reviews on this website. Overall, I am satisfied that my car got to CA safely and without major damage.

Couple things that I wish I knew, being a first-timer:

1. Honesty First wasn't actually the company that transported my car. They subcontracted the job to American Auto Transport, which has terrible reviews on this site. I wouldn't have chosen Honesty First if I knew American Auto Transport would be transporting my car. And no, I did not ask for a lower price when I received my quote. I went with it knowing there were cheaper options out there, in hopes that I would receive top-notch service.

2. My car arrived WAY too early. I know delivery times are never guaranteed, but when I booked my transport David all but assured me that there was no way the car would arrive faster than 7 days. I got a call from the truck driver within 3 days saying my car was ready to be picked up. When I asked if he could hold it until I arrived (which would have been 7 days after I shipped the car), he basically told me there was no way and I had to have somebody come meet him to get it. Well, it put me in a pretty tough spot being that I'm moving to a new city with no family or close friends. Neither the truck driver nor Honesty First seemed to concerned about the predicament I was in. I basically had to ask an acquaintance to spot me the $620 in cash to receive the car and keep the car for me for a few days. Not an ideal situation, but at least it got there safely.

3. The car arrived EXTREMELY dirty, which I can expect since it was shipped on an open-air container across country. However, my car also is covered with what appears to be oil spots, probably from another car that was on the truck that was leaking oil. I have no idea whether or not a nice car detailing will even get it out. Of course no company is going to say it's their fault, but maybe it would've been better if I just bought a car cover and asked for my car to be covered while in transport.

Overall, my car got to its final destination quickly and without major damage. After reading lots of nightmare reviews about other companies, I guess this wasn't so bad an experience.

Company Response
Michael Strickland from Ship a Car Direct Submitted this response.
Response Date: 5/23/2010 6:05:00 PM
GREAT stuff to learn from in Roger's review and through his experience, especially for anyone else that has never done this before, and that's probably most of you. I will address his points in the same manner he brings them up. 1. I am not sure where he missed the fact that we are a broker, it is all over our website, our emails and in the very first paragraph of the order terms. It is even on the very top of this review page with a link to verify such. Some people are very afraid of brokers, and rightfully so. But to give us one star for Honesty under those grounds is unwarranted, we never pretend to be anything other that what we are. We also do not require payment until you, the customer, have a chance to approve the chosen carrier, so if he didn't like American Auto he could have told us so and we would have found him another. That's one of the many ways that brokers help you. As for American Auto, they may have some bad reviews, it's the vocal minority that usually finds it's way back to this review site and others like it, but we have used them for years with no complaints. Most of our customers are pleased with their safe and efficient service, in fact, which leads us to... 2. Just as I know that David would never tell a customer that an order would never take MORE than 7 days, he would never tell a customer that it would not take LESS than seven days either. ALL dates are always estimates, keep that in mind. What I am sure that he informed Roger of was that the AVERAGE transit time for a move of that distance is, in fact, AROUND 7 days. Now, most customers would be thrilled to receive their car in 3 days on this move, and I understand the inconvenience of the situation that Roger found himself in, but it could have easily been avoided if he had told us up front of his need for a delivery restriction, so again, it is not entirely fair to fault us for not having this information in the first place. If you are not going to be able to accept your car until after a certain date, you need to make the company you choose aware of that. David and the rest of our staff will always ask about this if they see that the contact person is the same on each end, but in Roger's case, we were picking up from a different pickup contact and delivery to him with no notes of any issues, so if we are unaware of the problem, we cannot help you avoid the problem. As for the carriers, the vast majority cannot hold vehicles without charging storage, so make sure that you make the company you choose aware of any and all potential delivery issues up front. 3. Yes, on an open transport, your car WILL get dirty. That IS gauranteed (one of the few in this industry). It is impossible to cross the deserts of Texas, New Mexico, Arizona and Southern California without encountering dirt, whether you are driving your car or it's on a transport. It also sounds as if Roger has yet to wash his car as of his writing of this review, so my guess is that the black spots he refers to are more likely dead bugs, but I could be wrong. The oil-from-the-car-above scenario is more of an urban myth perpetuated by everyone's fears than a reality. But his point about the car cover is not valid and should not be taken as advice. Car covers are made for vehicles when they are stationary and would not (and should not) be used while in transit. Besides being an extreme liability if it were to blow off in traffic, the wind would continually whip that cover up against your car for 3000 miles, and when it arrived, you would weep at the condition it would leave your paint job in. Move past that idea right now, you can go in an enclosed transport if you choose, but realize that that is like flying first class and costs quite a bit more. I think once Roger has more time to reflect on his experience, and in comparison to the reviews of OTHER companies that he mentions, he will realize even more deeply the point that he makes about it really not being so bad an experience after all. He may even see fit to call us again, but I could be wrong about that too. Hope this review helped you in some way.